What Journalists Really Want From Your Media Pitch

Breaking through the noise has never been harder. With inboxes overflowing and media outlets under constant pressure, journalists are more selective than ever about which stories earn their attention. A successful media pitch today is no longer about volume or flashy language - it’s about relevance, clarity, and real value. Understanding what journalists actually want is the difference between being ignored and earning meaningful earned media coverage.

Journalists Want Originality, Not Generic Pitches

Journalists are inundated with recycled talking points and templated outreach, making originality a critical factor in pitch success. As Everything Branding notes, “Journalists are inundated with generic outreach every day, which is why relevance, clarity, and personalization matter more than ever.” (Everything Branding). A strong pitch immediately communicates what makes the story different, timely, and newsworthy. This means leading with a compelling angle and clearly answering a core question journalists ask instinctively: Why does this story matter right now?

Relevance to the Journalist’s Audience Is Essential

Relevance is non-negotiable. Journalists write for their readers, not for brands. Media pitches that fail to connect the story to an outlet’s specific beat or audience are quickly dismissed. Researching a journalist’s recent coverage and tailoring your pitch accordingly signals professionalism and respect - and significantly increases the likelihood of a response.

Earned Media Is Not Advertising

One of the most common pitching mistakes is treating earned media like paid advertising. Journalists are not looking for promotional copy. According to Everything Branding, “Brands that underestimate its strategic value often miss out on meaningful opportunities for authority, search visibility, and audience trust.” (Everything Branding). Effective pitches focus on insights, data, trends, or human-centered stories that contribute to a larger conversation. This approach positions brands as credible sources rather than advertisers and builds long-term media relationships.

Clarity and Efficiency Drive Results

Journalists are busy and under tight deadlines. Clear subject lines, strong opening sentences, and concise messaging matter. A focused pitch with a straightforward call to action is far more effective than a long, unfocused email that buries the point.

Why This Approach Works

When brands prioritize originality, audience relevance, and authentic storytelling, media pitching shifts from selling to serving. That’s what journalists want — and that’s how earned media works in today’s media landscape.

Ready to give your brand EVERYTHING?

Contact Us